I am curious what others do when your toys need to be retired.

Personally, I either throw them away, or offer them to somebody to try out or enjoy as a souvenir. The silicone plugs and dildos I own tend to break at the base, so once that starts, they're not usable for anyone. I've had a few items that were partially recyclable, or could be made into something else, but those are rare.

Usually by the time I am through with a toy it's pretty much ready for the trash heap. Like you, Mistress Genesis, if I like something I use it until it's all used up.

On the other hand, I have had toys that I didn't particularly like or that I upgraded that I have given away - usually to other Mistresses or sometimes to lifestyle players that I know that don't have the budget (or generous subs) to afford such toys.

You may also run into the conundrum that I do: some items are made for very large hands, and aren't as comfortable as Whips, slappers, etc... that I already have. Like you, I also give away those and other unwanted toys to those who'd most appreciate them.